Personally, I can think of 6 compelling reasons to go with the 04 over the base engine 05
But, if criteria like lighter weight, better MPG, "something new", the stick shift option, etc. are important to an Outback shopper, those are points in favor of the 05.
It will be interesting to hear from 05 owners what kind of insurance rate changes, if any, they are encountering due to the non-car designation- that could be a factor, too.
How's that for a noncommital response?
