The issue is this happens by itself without me switching the car off and on, that's just the only way I have found to reproduce the issue reliably.I dont think the vehicle is designed to be shut off at any speed. These are unexpected inputs in the "eyes" of the ECM...
...Just please stop endangering everyone on the road by shutting off your car at speed. When you do that you no longer have any power steering or brakes. I hope you knew this....or maybe not.
I obviously did this on an empty stretch of road, and I'm used to the feel of a car without power brakes and power steering, so I know what to expect. Thanks for your concern though.
I suspected that the RPM hold thing was some sort of "feature" the only problem is when you are driving and go to shift from 2nd to 3rd, but the engines RPM is just sitting at 2.5k and not settling, it can cause un-nessisary confusion and distraction when driving.Doesn't the 09 5mt have a rev match feature? Could this be a malfunction of that?
So would/could the dealer actually do something about this if I pointed it out to them?
And the rev matching thing still doesn't explain why sometimes the rev limiter kicks in at 4k RPM...
I miss old mechanical cars... You knew what to expect from them...