[1 Lucky Texan]

to me, it seems like the problem is in the mechanism right there under the console. you might find a diagram and some part numbers at www.opposedforces.com

the 'correct' way to adjust the brakes is with the 'star' adjusters on the rear hubs. But, the ratchet mechanism seem to be one of the problems you have.

 

[johnre]

It sounds like the spring that holds the ratchet engaged on the console handle is weak or broken (button sometimes stays depressed). And it also sounds like the cable has got some functional issue, since you said there is at times no resistance and no brake function. The two issues would normally seem to me to be independent of one another, but your symptoms suggest they may be correlated.

In any case, do as Texan suggests and start with the console side to see what's going on there.

 

[v2rocket]

the mechanism is super easy to get to, i believe there's 2 screws under the "console lid" and then the whole plastic panel surrounding the lever pulls out. then everything is accessible right there...

 

[Probiz]

I'll be starting with the spring mechanism below the handle, because with a little bit of a lateral wiggle I can manage to get the parking brake to hold the car solidly after a try or two. If that doesn't mend it, I'll just have to work my way backwards with the cable and finally the adjustment at the rear brake hubs. Thanks for the advice! Will update periodically.

 

[Probiz]

Finally got into the handbrake assembly, turns out it is in fact the internal handle button spring that manipulates the small black metal latch that goes up the quarter circle shaped toothed gear. Can someone please provide guidance on how to remove the handle and replace that spring. Thanks!

 

[1 Lucky Texan]

you may be served well by getting an assembly from a local wrecking yard.

if no one here has info for you, ask also at ultimatesubaru.org .


I once read of someone replacing the button with a modified ball point pen cap - if you could find that, maybe there's disassembly info also?

 

[Probiz]

If I were to replace the whole assembly, could you explain how to remove the whole thing? I don't mind removing the whole assembly to take a stab at just repairing the handle spring. I'm also looking to purchase a repair manual shortly, that will probably be beneficial. Does Bentley make a Subaru Legacy repair manual? Not a huge fan of Haynes manuals.

 

[johnre]

Does Bentley make a Subaru Legacy repair manual? Not a huge fan of Haynes manuals.

Subaru Factory Service Manuals (FSM) - Every Model - USDM/EU

Looks like they have 1999.

 

[splitboarder]

I have the same problem. Mine is because the first owners dogs chewed the end up. I also have to thump mine up and down to get the spring to pop out.
I have to replace the actual handle. I don't think you can fix that inner spring

 

[Probiz]

I have the same problem. Mine is because the first owners dogs chewed the end up. I also have to thump mine up and down to get the spring to pop out.
I have to replace the actual handle. I don't think you can fix that inner spring

I ordered a Haynes manual, hopefully it explains how to remove the whole handle. I'm just gonna go that way with it than try to fix the spring itself.