I like the tube bumpers & thats what I would go with for sure, yet the 2nd one was just too big & looked heavy, wouldn't want all that weight up front probably hurts the handling of the car..I am having trouble at the moment finding the uglier one I was thinking of. When I get more time, I'll do some more checking. Wait, here it is. http://img523.imageshack.us/img523/2724/4x4learnerday019aan8.jpg
Just my opinion, but this one just doesn't flow well to me.