Piston Slap or knocking?
I had noticed this when I first got the car, but then it got warm out and I didn't hear it again. Or if the car sits for a while I notice it as well.
So here it is. When I start the car when it's cold out it is rather loud, sounds like knocking, I assume piston slap. The longer it has sat the longer it goes for.
If the car has sat for a long period of time(a week or more) it starts super rough and then the noise last longer.
So my question is any idea what this might be? Is it due to oil draining out of the cylinders or what?
As for the cold, would an engine block heater help alleviate this problem?
I normally wouldn't worry too much, but it sounds horrendous. Especially when it has sat for a while.
So here it is. When I start the car when it's cold out it is rather loud, sounds like knocking, I assume piston slap. The longer it has sat the longer it goes for.
If the car has sat for a long period of time(a week or more) it starts super rough and then the noise last longer.
So my question is any idea what this might be? Is it due to oil draining out of the cylinders or what?
As for the cold, would an engine block heater help alleviate this problem?
I normally wouldn't worry too much, but it sounds horrendous. Especially when it has sat for a while.
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
the link below may help. i think it says that rod noise will go away if you unplug the spark plug. but you better read it to be sure.
i would read up on piston slap. nothing is going to correct it short of replacing the pistons. but a different oil more lessen the noise a bit. for some reason i seem to remember a havoline 5w40 being a good choice. but you need to do some reading. i think i read about piston slap and oil on the ''ultimatesubaru.org'' site. try searching ''piston slap oil* '' keep the asterisk but lose the quotes.
Engine Noise Diagnosis 101
i would read up on piston slap. nothing is going to correct it short of replacing the pistons. but a different oil more lessen the noise a bit. for some reason i seem to remember a havoline 5w40 being a good choice. but you need to do some reading. i think i read about piston slap and oil on the ''ultimatesubaru.org'' site. try searching ''piston slap oil* '' keep the asterisk but lose the quotes.
Engine Noise Diagnosis 101
Joined
·
1 Posts
piston slap redux
i've had my 98 legacy wagon now for 5 years.it has 174k and the piston slap is part of it's behavior.she sounds like a diesel when first started but after she warms up she quiets down.i've tried every brand and type of oil to no avail.so,i got used to her infirmity.besides,the fix makes no sense,money wise.
i've had my 98 legacy wagon now for 5 years.it has 174k and the piston slap is part of it's behavior.she sounds like a diesel when first started but after she warms up she quiets down.i've tried every brand and type of oil to no avail.so,i got used to her infirmity.besides,the fix makes no sense,money wise.
Joined
·
2 Posts
I kept going back to this video with different speakers. My phone makes it sound one way, the laptop speakers sound another and external speaker surround makes it different again. But, the high pitch is lifters, lower tone sounds like a rod bearing. Got Oil?
That's not good.
Yeah, I don't really know what to do about it, other than change the oil regularly at shorter intervals(already do that). And change the filter regularly. I haven't been able to diagnose where the sound is coming from, or where the shavings are from. I thought maybe it was due to the leak, and I had let the oil get to low. The leak is fixed now so we will see what happens.
I've heard Subaru of America has a remedy in some cases but it involves a new set of pistons. My 2001 does the same thing. Break-in is important !!!, don't over rev and drive in short spurts with cool downs between. Think "Heat Cycles" , and break in according to MFG. Also for those symptomatic motors, warm up is important, block heater is awesome in winter. Don't over-rev and you may get a long service life. I'm thinking at least until head gasket issues happen and then it's time for pistons also. Then ur ready for another 300 K !!!
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
