The Subaru mats left the area under the gas pedal unprotected and the dead pedal as well. The WeatherTech mats cover these areas as well as the side of the center console and door sill where you would otherwise leave dirt/mud from your shoes. I peeled the WeatherTech logo off the mats and no residue was left behind.I have the Subaru mats and am very happy with their coverage.
Maybe Weathertech mats are better? I just don't see a problem with the OEMs.