Subaru Outback Forums banner

Anyone find a good MP3 player to work in the USB slot

14K views 20 replies 16 participants last post by  Skinny Dennis  
#1 ·
I am tired of my trips taking less time than USB sticks to index and then the navigation is poor anyway. My iPod keeps locking up in the car, which I suspect is a serial port speed mismatch of some kind and needing a reset. Even my iphone can be hit or miss. Wondering if anyone has found a good solution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zim2dive and OBnube
#5 ·
Use fast USB sticks (with high read speeds), limit number of files and folders.
Folder structure matters a LOT. Some systems prefer everything being in the root directory, others can't handle that many files in one directory easily. Avoid more than one folder deep nesting, if you use folders at all. Lastly, if you don't let the head unit finish indexing the files, it may be having to start over every time, from scratch.
 
#7 ·
I have a high speed 32gb stick set up artist/album/song and it takes a solid 5 minutes to fully index. On restart it only remembers the song being played. It then indexes first to last added to the stick. I'm getting really tired of the first song indexed. Also if I use another input on start-up it won't start indexing until I access it. WTF?!!! I set up a second USB with a no folder 150 MP3 playlist and it takes a minute or so to index. I still can't get any WMA or WAV files to play. This is a MAJOR fail.

This is a regression from my 2013. It would always stay fully indexed and remember last song for USB and CD input. It would play virtually any file but Flac. Truly plug and play. How this new indexing metric ever made it to prime time is a mystery.
 
#8 ·
I have been pretty happy with my second gen FIIO X3. Uses microSD card (up to 128 GB) for storage. Does take some time to index, and it needs to reindex every startup. I have about 60GB on the card at present and my library is always growing. Within a minute or so, even while indexing, you can do a sort of page down between albums.

I chose against iPod touch because I already have an iPhone and getting one with enough storage to contain my library was more costly than I thought was reasonable. $299 for new 64 GB. Not sure about refurb as right now they only have 32 GB. $400 for a new 128 GB for $399? To play music through a marginally ok HU? No way. The FIIO can be had for at most $170 (without SD card). Add the 128 GB microSD card and you are looking at 128 GB of storage for $210 or so and the sound quality is amazing.
 
#9 ·
So are you playing this through the HK HU? What interface are you using? USB? AUX jack? You say the sound is "amazing". Is that better or the same sound from an iPod. I had an iPod laying around that I have not used since getting into the iPhones and just loaded that up with the music I want and leave it in the car. It seems to be ready to use moments after starting the car.
 
#11 ·
I am connecting the FIIO via USB . I DID have an iPod classic that was faster in spite of the fact that it had a platter drive rather than ssd/microSD. Lost it. I was not able to find a reasonably priced new classic (120 GB) so went for the FIIO. I do think it sounds better than my iPod, either the lost classic or the shuffle that I still have. But these are my ears and I think my statements about the quality should be taken as subjective.